When a Roth conversion DOES NOT Make Sense

Watch Time: 13:44
Peter Richon ·
October 3, 2026

According to Fidelity, Roth IRA conversions jumped 41% in the first quarter of 2026 compared with the same period last year. 📈

But before you convert, as Peter Richon with Richon Planning explains to Erin Kennedy, there are some important situations to consider. You may want to think twice if:

💵 You can’t pay the tax bill with cash
📊 You’re still working and in a high tax bracket
🏥 You’re approaching Medicare and a conversion could trigger an IRMAA surcharge
❤️ You’re charitably minded and a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD) may provide a better tax benefit

In this interview, Peter breaks down these potential Roth conversion pitfalls—and why the right strategy depends on your income, age, tax bracket and overall retirement plan. Before making a decision, call 919-300-5886 or visit www.RichonPlanning.com

💰💰💰 Financial confidence through educated planning💰💰💰
Be SMART with your money with Peter Richon at Richon Planning!!!

00:00:03
[music] Peter, so good to see you. Welcome back everyone. Today we are going to talk through when a Roth conversion does not make sense. So listen to this Peter. According to Fidelity, Roth IRA conversions jump 41% in the first quarter of 2026 compared to 2025. But that doesn’t mean a Roth conversion is right for you. So let’s talk through when a conversion does not make sense. On the other hand of that coin though, we just recorded a video on when a Roth conversion does make sense. So if our

00:00:34
viewers and listeners have time, make sure you listen to both. Before we get to it though, what is a Roth conversion? >> Well, a Roth conversion is reclassifying dollars that you have already placed in a taxdeerred account. So this is not adding additional new money. This is not a contribution. This is converting over the dollars that are already there and present in a tax deferred account such as a 401k or a traditional IRA, paying the tax on those dollars now today, and moving them over

00:01:10
to an account where all of the future growth and income will be tax-free if you follow the rules. Now, uh, we did that video on when to do a Roth conversion, Aaron, and I noted, you know, with this, uh, Fidelity report that they, uh, the the number of conversions is up 41% in the first quarter. That that just that headline alone indicates that maybe not everybody is doing them correctly. Um, I worry about doing them too early in the year. Not everybody retires of their own accord, on their own timeline. What if

00:01:46
we get laid off and need to take distributions? What if we receive a severance? So there there is a benefit for doing Roth conversions. We can’t ignore that. We should be looking at that very carefully, but we also want to be very careful about when and how we’re executing them, >> right? Okay. So let’s jump into when a conversion does not make sense. First reason, and you have I have recorded a separate video about this one point in and of itself. If you can’t pay the tax

00:02:15
bill with cash, why? >> Yeah. Well, there I mean there’s a good, better, best way to do it. Um, you can use the money inside of the IRA itself to pay the tax if you are 59 and a half or above, but the goal of the conversion is to get as much money into the Roth as possible. And so, if you’re using the money from the converted value itself, then that goal is not being achieved. we are we are actually going to convert over and receive less on the Roth side of things. And if you compare it apples

00:02:52
to apples, say that we were going to pay $10,000 in taxes for this conversion one way or another. Well, $10,000 in the Roth account grows tax-free for your future income and future legacy and inheritance. Whereas $10 $10,000 that’s in the bank, when that money grows, you’re taxed again on the growth. You get a $1099 int. And so there there’s not necessarily a wrong way to pay the tax on a conversion, but there is definitely a better way to do it. And it’s best to do it out of after tax

00:03:31
cash, not from the converted amount itself, if at all possible. And then before 59 a half, absolutely do not do it with the converted amount because that is actually considered a pre 59 12 premature withdrawal. And not only will you have to pay the tax, but there will be an additional 10% penalty on the amount that you just used to pay the tax. And who wants to pay a penalty on money they’re paying taxes with? >> Not me. >> No one. >> All right. Another sub optimal time. If

00:04:04
you are still working and in your prime earning years, how does my tax bracket factor into my decision? >> Well, I mean, it’s it’s it’s all a matter of calculating out when to pay the lowest taxes strategically. And if you are in your peak earning years, chances are those are not your lowest tax years. You’re probably earning well up into our progressive tax brackets. And as you can see on the screen, the more that you make, the more you pay in taxes. I know that’s been a a big buzz

00:04:38
theme of the last decade or so. It’s already actually how our tax system works. As you move through these tiers, you pay a greater and greater percentage of your income in taxes. So if you’re for instance in the 32% tax bracket today, why would you voluntarily convert over additional dollars that would be charged 32% or more in taxes when in all likelihood in retirement, maybe just a few years away, you could pull those dollars out of a tax deferred account across those lower tax brackets and pay

00:05:14
less in tax. So, it is an individual matter because >> it’s somebody’s specific income and projections for what their expenses are in retirement. And there’s also maybe a case to be made for it’s easier to pay a bill out of my paycheck while I’m earning it rather than out of my finite retirement nest egg once I’m no longer earning a paycheck. But if you are in those higher earnings years and therefore higher tax brackets, maybe I would look at how you are contributing

00:05:50
new money before I looked at converting over a large lump sum of previously saved tax deferred capital. >> Okay, number three here, Irma. If you are 63, a Roth conversion could have you paying a Medicare sir charge. And again, if you are new to our channel and Peter is a wonderful YouTube resource library, we have a whole separate video on what is Irma, but please continue. Peter >> Irma 63, but I thought Medicare didn’t start until 65. >> It has a two-year look back. Peter, you

00:06:24
should watch our video. >> Look back. We would have answered that question. Exactly. Right. Um, yeah. So, Medicare premiums for part B and part D are inteed. They are means tested. The more you make, the more you earn, the more taxable income you have, the more you’re going to pay for part B and part D. And doing a Roth conversion can cause people unintended consequences of higher Medicare premiums. So, not only do we have the tax to deal with, but now we get surprised by these higher Medicare

00:07:00
insurance premiums. It can cause un unforeseen unintended consequences in those costs and expenses. And yes, Medicare does look back to years. So, you need to be awful careful with this starting at age 63. >> All right. Number four. If you are charitably minded and 70 and a half and donating money already to another church or charity, a qualified charitable distribution may provide a greater tax benefit than an earlier conversion. So, how do I know which one is better for me? >> Well, it depends on your goals. Uh, is

00:07:35
it your goal to gift and give away this money, or is it your goal that these dollars are for you in your lifetime purposes or your spouse’s lifetime purposes or your family as part of a legacy. If you are charitably inclined, then a QCD is a wonderful way to make that gift to a qualifying 501c3 nonprofit, church, charity, what have you. Um, that you can gift money directly out of your IRA and skip the tax ability all together and that your charity can receive that gift tax-free is a wonderful opportunity. We don’t

00:08:16
have very many opportunities for truly tax-free money, but we earned the money and we put it into a tax deferred account where it grew and now our goal is charitable inclinations. We we we are charitably inclined and want to give some of that money away. After 70 and a half, do that out of your IRA, not out of cash. However, if the money is intended for your life purposes, then looking at these Roth conversions could make sense. Again, we’ve got to weigh it. We’ve got to talk to the individual.

00:08:51
What are your goals? How much do you envision giving to that charity? You can gift and give away up to $100,000 per year with these uh QCDs. So, it’s it’s a big opportunity as well as a valuable opportunity, but if we are planning on doing that, we probably would not want to convert over those dollars in a Roth conversion. Eric, >> okay. And you have a bonus when a Roth conversion does not make sense. And that is if you haven’t taken your required minimum distribution. Explain this one,

00:09:23
please. >> Yeah. So hopefully people did watch that previous video and know and understand that you cannot convert over your RMD directly. But that does not mean that you can’t be simultaneously taking and satisfying the RMD requirement as well as additionally doing Roth conversions. However, big caveat on this. The first money out of an IRA account or a tax deferred account once you are of RMD age is always going to be considered the RMD. So you don’t want to convert over an amount until you

00:10:07
have satisfied the RMD. That’s really going to muddy the water. the money that you just converted over and paid tax on and landed in the Roth account is now going to be considered part of that RMD amount. And so that really is is going to cause a lot of headaches. Just do it cleanly. Take your RMD, satisfy your RMD, and then make the Roth conversion. And oh, by the way, by taking the RMD, now you have some aftert tax cash that you can use to pay the bill on the conversion so more money lands up over

00:10:41
in the Roth. >> Clear as mud, Peter. >> Absolutely. >> Thanks to the IRS for keeping this all straightforward for us. >> Well, there’s only 70 some odd thousand pages of tax codes, >> right? No, that’s why I have you. I am so grateful for your time, Peter, to talk this through. And again, friendly reminder to everybody who found us on YouTube or otherwise, we have a great video resource library that you can kind of digest at your own time. I feel like we’ve done a video on every one of these

00:11:08
points separately, Peter, but also, as you mentioned, the five best times for a Roth conversion. That being said, devil’s in the details. The math is going to be different with everybody. If somebody wants to sit down with you and talk through whether a Roth conversion makes sense for them, how can they get a hold of you? Well, after they like and subscribe and share to the YouTube channel so that they can get more information, then they can give me a call at 9193005886 and set up a time to talk. And we do put

00:11:34
together the optimized retirement plan for listeners and viewers of the program at no cost. That’s a courtesy service that we offer. We believe everyone should have a plan that’s not just about access to the market and how to invest, but how those investments will actually be utilized and how much of them you get to keep. So, bringing together all five of the critical pillars of income, investments, taxes, health care, and legacy, and how all of those apply to your specific situation. That’s what the

00:12:04
optimized retirement plan is all about. Again, no cost. Just give us a call and uh we can put that together with you. 9193005886 919-3005886. You can also start that process online. You can visit our website ranplanning.com. It looks like rich onplanning. Rashanplanning.com. And we do have that handy dandy online retirement tax bill calculator. the the tool that shows you what the IRS hopes to collect from you versus what you could plan and prepare effectively and potentially bring that bill down to on

00:12:41
your tax deferred accounts. And the difference is eyeopening. So go to 919retired.com and you can enter in your information, run your own numbers and see the results right there. 919retired.com. [music] >> Great. A lot of resources. Peter, thank you so much for your time today. I appreciate it. >> Thank you, Erin. Always good to see you. The content of this radio show is provided forformational purposes only and is not a solicitation or recommendation of any investment strategy. You are [music] encouraged to

00:13:16
seek investment, tax, or legal advice from an independent professional adviser. Any investments and/or investment strategies mentioned involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Advisory services offered through Brooks Zone Capital Management, a registered investment adviser. Fiduciary duty extends solely to investment advisory advice and does not extend to other activities such as insurance or broker dealer services. Advisory clients are charged a quarterly fee [music] for assets under management,

00:13:39
while insurance products pay a commission, which may result in a conflict of interest regarding compensation.

Subscribe
Submit Topics and Questions to be Covered in Future Episodes

View Past Episodes

November 7, 2026

Planning Matters Radio | 🏡 Is a Continuing Care Retirement Community Right for You?

November 2, 2026

⛷️ New Retirement Trend: Spend Your Kids’ Inheritance! 💸

October 24, 2026

Planning Matters Radio | How To Make Your kids Rich

Begin Your
Optimized Retirement Plan™

Let’s make sure you feel empowered and prepared for what “someday” will bring.